Battery charge remaining.
- Thread starter Sarah Winfield
- Start date
The problem is improper testing will give a false reading...
sure you will know the battery at a gross level... compared to a good tester, this one uses the same load for ALL 1.5 volt batteries... too steep for AA and AAA and a bit too lightweight for C and D
So by saving a few pounds on something that should last a number of years, you may be throwing out good batteries in some cases, and not detecting ones that are giving electronics fits.
There's no long term savings, a cheap tool is a cheap tool.
Unfortunately there is a lot to be made in the battery business. I have one that has different settings for button cells, AA & AAA, and C & D, not to mention other voltage batteries.
So to me, looking at cost savings over even a few years, a worthless purchase COMPARED TO a slightly better device...
Greg
sure you will know the battery at a gross level... compared to a good tester, this one uses the same load for ALL 1.5 volt batteries... too steep for AA and AAA and a bit too lightweight for C and D
So by saving a few pounds on something that should last a number of years, you may be throwing out good batteries in some cases, and not detecting ones that are giving electronics fits.
There's no long term savings, a cheap tool is a cheap tool.
Unfortunately there is a lot to be made in the battery business. I have one that has different settings for button cells, AA & AAA, and C & D, not to mention other voltage batteries.
So to me, looking at cost savings over even a few years, a worthless purchase COMPARED TO a slightly better device...
Greg
Greg, the issue is, is it cost effective for the average battery user to have multiple testers, most of use find something is not working, is it the battery. If it is well in the green probably not, if it is in the red probably is, and if it is in the middle try a new set of batteries to see if it make a difference. It is JUST a guide. Sorry but all those testers sitting around doing nothing for months or years is a waste. When did I last change a C or D cell, can't remember, of buying a tester for them is worthless. Here is how I manage my batteries:
-
1
-
1
-
1
- Show all
Semantics, but perhaps we could agree that the cheaper 'testers' should actually be referred to as :
Battery Condition Indicators
And agree that for us mere mortals, they give a 'go', 'no-go', or '-ish' indication of the state of a cell.
Someone dealing with batteries in a professional capacity, may-well require something better?
PhilP
Battery Condition Indicators
And agree that for us mere mortals, they give a 'go', 'no-go', or '-ish' indication of the state of a cell.
Someone dealing with batteries in a professional capacity, may-well require something better?
PhilP
-
3
- Show all
I have a similar beast to that, tested out the AA’s today and 21 heading towards Lidl recycling bin next time I visit. And as
PhilP
says testers probably only an indicator but my Crest Handsets soon shows if AA batteries are no good by a 3 bar indication and pretty soon after 2 bars loosing both range and reliability of operation by just turning off.-
2
-
1
- Show all
No, I NEVER suggested getting multiple testers.... what post of mine says that?
I agree that would be stupid... but you are the first person mentioning getting multiple testers.
What I am saying is to save a few pounds and get something much less capable is worthless, considering the cost of time and batteries.
I have one tester I use for virtually all Alkaline batteries, and have had it for years. I have received many "free" testers over the years, and they are worth exactly what I paid for them, nothing.
I agree that would be stupid... but you are the first person mentioning getting multiple testers.
What I am saying is to save a few pounds and get something much less capable is worthless, considering the cost of time and batteries.
I have one tester I use for virtually all Alkaline batteries, and have had it for years. I have received many "free" testers over the years, and they are worth exactly what I paid for them, nothing.
My rechargeable AA batteries are now being recharged.
"The Midas Touch" is an afliction where everything King Midas touched turned to gold. If there is an opposite affliction where everything touched turns to "s***" then I have that afliction.
In order to replace the tyres on my Playmobil yellow diesel I dropped the chassis. Having discovered the locomotive then no longer ran I retraced my steps, dropped the chassis again and discovered that a small plug had left its socket.
I'm not confident I have found my problem but live in hope that the locomotive will now run!
I am grateful for all the replies to my initial enquiry.
Thank you.
PS I have new PP3's for the controller.
"The Midas Touch" is an afliction where everything King Midas touched turned to gold. If there is an opposite affliction where everything touched turns to "s***" then I have that afliction.
In order to replace the tyres on my Playmobil yellow diesel I dropped the chassis. Having discovered the locomotive then no longer ran I retraced my steps, dropped the chassis again and discovered that a small plug had left its socket.
I'm not confident I have found my problem but live in hope that the locomotive will now run!
I am grateful for all the replies to my initial enquiry.
Thank you.
PS I have new PP3's for the controller.
Apologies, you said a tester with multiple settings for multiple battery types, again though a step to far for the average user.
Here are some examples currently available:
This one is exactly the one I have, purchases (with different branding) 20 years ago:
The button cells go in the slot on the right and you push down on the dark gray part to make the connection.
There are great, inexpensive products that will last you a lifetime for purchase... trying to save a couple of dollars on a 20 year investment is worthless in my opinion. I'm sure you can find this on Amazon UK.
This one is exactly the one I have, purchases (with different branding) 20 years ago:
The button cells go in the slot on the right and you push down on the dark gray part to make the connection.
There are great, inexpensive products that will last you a lifetime for purchase... trying to save a couple of dollars on a 20 year investment is worthless in my opinion. I'm sure you can find this on Amazon UK.
Very neat and tidy! You've embarrassed me know, mine are keep in the original boxes
Take your pick https://www.amazon.co.uk/s?k=Alkali...ine+battery+testers,aps,1277&ref=nb_sb_noss_2 You can even get Jimmy's with the battery organiser (a cheap waste of money ?). So what would you recommend, Greg, from this lot of hopefully, in-stock and UK Amazon supplied products ? Have fun.
From the RS Components link I posted, judging by price, this might be their "quality, last a lifetime" option 4000392 | Ansmann Energy Check LCD Battery Tester For Various Battery | RS
Max
From the RS Components link I posted, judging by price, this might be their "quality, last a lifetime" option 4000392 | Ansmann Energy Check LCD Battery Tester For Various Battery | RS
Max
Last edited:
I did the Amazon search using
Greg Elmassian
link, and what I didn't find was mention this varying load test for different battery types (in most cases). I am happy with mine, I didn't waste my money, and will stick with it. The important think is Mrs B can use it, not sure she would use the more complex ones, so the batteries would just be changed, making the expensive complex ones an even bigger waste of money 
-
2
-
1
- Show all
I'm waiting more in hope than expectation for a replacent battery tester being sent for the faulty one I received.I did the Amazon search using
On a more positive note my locomotive now works. It must have been the un-connected plug causeing a lack of movement.
At the moment though it is very wet in my garden and I only run my train in the dry.
What with my problems I haven't yet enjoyed my shunting layout but I live in hope.
-
5
-
1
- Show all
Battery tester update.
After reading the replies to this subject I ordered myself a battery storage tray which included a built in tester of the same design as the cheap one., (I use ebay as it is convenient and delivery was free)
The tray arrived this morning and low and behold it is just what I need and the tester actually works!
If the replacement for the faulty one arrives I'll now have two testers.
Unfortunately the weather down here on the south coast is very wet so no opportunity yet to run my shunting layout.
Thank you again to those who replied to my subject.
Sarah Winfield
-
3
-
1
- Show all
