Its funny, Roundhouse seem to habitually outshop their locos in an all over gloss finish, Accucraft UK in satin. You see a lot of people on forums toning down their smokeboxes, at least, to a matt finish but retaining the gloss or satin colour paint work. As Jon says a matter of personal taste. I prefer an all over satin look, both locos and rolling stock as that seems the default in other products throughout the various scales. Max