Started this in another thread, and suggestion was a thread of its own.
A couple of weeks ago my Bachmann Caboose kept de-railing going through a LGB R1 point, and lots of comments on B2B size and reverse curve etc, but at the time left it as it was. Earlier this week my Bachmann Lumber wagon was de-railing on a different R1 point, and initial thoughts suggested the wheel set was the issue.
When first set up I was sure that everything traversed all the routes in all direction, so why de-rail now, well I had changed to Bachmann metal wheels. I removed the metal wheels and replaced the plastic wheels, heh no problem.
So this morning I got down to take some photos:
This is the plastic wheel set, outside wheel flange hard against the check rail, and you will see the inside wheel is in the "frog well":
View media item 3329
I then placed the metal wheel set in the same position, outside wheel flange hard against the check rail, and you will see the inside wheel is sitting on the frog:
View media item 3328
So placing the wheel sets next to each other, though the B2B is within 0.5 mm of each other inner flange on one wheel to outer flange on the other wheel seems to be about 1.5 mm different (metal wheel being the larger size):
View media item 3330
The issue does seem to be with the wheels and not the points, though I am sure R1 point don't help.
A couple of weeks ago my Bachmann Caboose kept de-railing going through a LGB R1 point, and lots of comments on B2B size and reverse curve etc, but at the time left it as it was. Earlier this week my Bachmann Lumber wagon was de-railing on a different R1 point, and initial thoughts suggested the wheel set was the issue.
When first set up I was sure that everything traversed all the routes in all direction, so why de-rail now, well I had changed to Bachmann metal wheels. I removed the metal wheels and replaced the plastic wheels, heh no problem.
So this morning I got down to take some photos:
This is the plastic wheel set, outside wheel flange hard against the check rail, and you will see the inside wheel is in the "frog well":
View media item 3329
I then placed the metal wheel set in the same position, outside wheel flange hard against the check rail, and you will see the inside wheel is sitting on the frog:
View media item 3328
So placing the wheel sets next to each other, though the B2B is within 0.5 mm of each other inner flange on one wheel to outer flange on the other wheel seems to be about 1.5 mm different (metal wheel being the larger size):
View media item 3330
The issue does seem to be with the wheels and not the points, though I am sure R1 point don't help.