LGB 2045 RhB loco review & questions

This was a setting that was around when analogue was the only option. If you had multiple locos on the same track, when you turn the controller, they will all move unless had isolated track sections for parking locos. The 0 setting meant you could leave a loco in a siding and wouldn't run while you were playing with the other(s).

Although I see the point - I don't think it's the same situation. Battery is an option but not the future and it isn't such a paradigm shift that track power will disappear entirely because it is so superior. There simply isn't enough demand for battery so I think @Software Tools summarises it well.
There indeed may not be enough demand for commercial battery power though it should be noted that Piko have dipped their feet in the water with their 25tonner Track Cleaning locomotive (plus other variations of the same machine?). However after market conversion is very much practiced and I know at least 3 in the forum that are now pretty well exclusively battery powered for former track powered locomotives and many that have the odd one or two to be able to ‘run something’ for guests when cleaning the complete line is not really an option.
 
Track power is also very 'G scale centric' within the larger scales..

Many (most?) SM32 (16mm,15mm) tracks are dead-rail. - Much of the stock not having insulated wheels.
This makes BPRC pretty much a 'given'.

Gauge O is predominantly track powered. - Much still DC. Even out into the garden, but once outside, there is a growing trend towards BPRC.

Gauge 1 seems to be pretty mixed, between live steam, track and battery.

I have limited knowledge of Gauge 3, but it appears to be very similar to SM32/16mm.

Rabid generalisations, from my own observations.

PhilP.
 
Battery is an option but not the future and it isn't such a paradigm shift that track power will disappear entirely because it is so superior.

I can see the advantage of track power when having a very big layout with many trains and complex operations.

But for small hobbyists like me with tiny layout and few locos, track power alone is unsuitable. My love affair with railways come and go in phases. Sometimes I run trains daily and sometimes I don't even touch the trains for months. In the outdoor track, when I try to run trains after 4-5 months gap, the track becomes non-conductive and running trains became frustrating experience. Battery has resolved it. If track looks clean visually then trains always run fine with battery.

I use track power only in my tiny indoor layout. I have a slightly larger layout outdoor but use it sparingly and can only use battery because tracks are not clean to carry electric. For outdoor run I need to wear jackets, bring trains from shed, take them away after running and baby sit in the cold & rain (most of the year is like that in UK). With indoor, no such problem - trains kept on track all the time, I can just switch on power and make them run while working in adjacent room and then when I'm done just turn the power off. Hence, having option to run locos in dual mode (track + battery) is useful feature to have.

Battery does not even require tracks to be metal, which reduces cost of expanding layout outdoor as plastic, makeshift wood planks etc. can be used for tracks (for straight sections).

Manufacturers like LGB cater for those with industrial scale layouts. They are in the market to make profit, so can't blame them. I bought an LGB starter set many years back but after that I only bought used LGB/Playmobil stuff. So I am not LGB's target market.

Roundhouse makes battery locos but with very high price tags. But used LGB locos + DIY battery conversion is lot cheaper. If locos come with sockets, then the task becomes far simpler.

Piko has released one battery model (though not great looking). Some smaller scale (O/HO/OO) manufacturers have started making battery operated locos. So may be this trend will expand to G scale one day - only time will tell.

I believe there are many small G scale hobbyists like me. Not everyone joins online forums. So, there is probably an invisible market with different needs.

Now even real life trains can run in battery
 
Track power is also very 'G scale centric' within the larger scales..

Many (most?) SM32 (16mm,15mm) tracks are dead-rail. - Much of the stock not having insulated wheels.
This makes BPRC pretty much a 'given'.

Gauge O is predominantly track powered. - Much still DC. Even out into the garden, but once outside, there is a growing trend towards BPRC.

Gauge 1 seems to be pretty mixed, between live steam, track and battery.

I have limited knowledge of Gauge 3, but it appears to be very similar to SM32/16mm.

Rabid generalisations, from my own observations.

PhilP.
Gauge 3 bods tend to be Battery powered or live steam. Even the show layouts are battery powered as a rule though there was a broup that did a big G3 St.Ives (Cornwall) layout with track power using Massoth handsets, certainly the exception to my knowledge as a G3 member.
 
Back
Top Bottom