Trader, eh? Well, having just passed my 80th, I suppose the Eaglecliff Logging and Lumber Railroad isn't going to run forever, especially if we decide to decamp Up North, so what is the market like from your point of view? I have realised that model shops are getting like hens' teeth, and a recent appeal, albeit half-hearted, to my local G scale group produced no response whatsoever, apart from an old acquaintance who asked after me, but only runs clockwork or somesuch... My 4-4-0 is still available, new, from the US, at around $1500, but the current range of new stuff over there otherwise appears to be approximately zilch. Am I sitting on a small fortune in rarities, or is it "buy one, get three free?"
Is that the 2-6-0, close relative (an alternate version, in fact) of your 4-4-0, as used in your icon ? I have 2 in that guise, they are both sometimes referred to as "Centennials", as a generic term.
I have an "RGS" liveried original mk 1 from around 20 years ago the other the improved mk 2 version in the "Glenbrook" livery. That latter mk 2 was bought from ANA Kramer on Ebay (a US close out specialist) about 5 years ago. I think I paid £400 for that. $1500 sounds like one of Bachmann's loopy RRP's. One of my favourite locos. Loved they were so diminutive in real life that a lot of people think they are 1:22.5 and not the "Spectrum" standard of 1:20.3 for nearly all their D&RGW, and logging, stuff. Pop an Accucraft J&S on the back can appear odd but is prototypicaly accurate.
Well made locos. Yes, plastic construction for body and chassis, with metal motions, valvegear, wheels and other details. They can be fiddly if assembly/disassembly needs doing. Their scale Stephenson valvegear is a nightmare, untill you get the knack of how to do it. Clever design throughout, with the sliding cab windows (is that what you mentioned ?) held in by the cab roof on their top edges, cab sides lower.
The earlier version had a reputation for the main axle drive gear splitting. Which requires the disassembly of that valve gear to get to - which is how I got the knack. Wheel nuts under caps on wheel hub. Both Bachman and NSW made replacement gears, at some point - brass (which I used) and Delrin respectively.
Main 2 differences between the Mk 1 and Mk 2 -
1) The later version had revised electrics that used their standard Plug & Play (PnP) PCB board, mounted in the tender, instead of the basic PcB's in main loco frames. This revision made conversion to R/C, battery, sound (Mk 1 has axle chuff triggers) and DCC operations a much easier proposition than the very basic set up in the Mk 1. My "Glendale" is due for the RC/battery/sound conversion. My Mk 1 has been converted to RC/battery with sound - avoiding using the chuff triggers.
2) The biggest, and most beneficial, change on the Mk 2 was change to metal gears in the transmission. This gets round the, terminal for some users, transmission maladies. Otherwise, from what I can see, most detail and superstructure parts - motions, cab, tender trucks, valvegear, etc' - are interchangeable between mk 1 & 2. Although there are limitations between 2-6-0 & 4-4-0 for rods and transmissions. There may be some mounting modification on major chassis/superstructure moldings to cater for the modified transmission and electrics between mk 1 & 2.
Post pictures of what you want to fix and I'll se if I can advise. Max
My mk 1 2-6-0. Pictures from around 18 years ago. Ezzie passed in 2010

